Advice column featuring
"woman to woman straight talk"
with clear insights into real problems.  Don't forget to Ask Claire
about YOUR problem.

 


About Claire Seven Principles Free Subscription My Question

Recent Columns:
Bridge over Waters
Father of Bride

Past Columns:
Wildlife Park
Nine Yards
Pre Grand-Opening
Under His Thumb
Attack of Vampires
Tea and Sympathy
Brave as a Lion
Torn

Underachiever
Pickled
Load o'Bull
For the Birds
Employee from Hell

Ring Around the Rosie
Share the Cutie Already
Rubber Bands
Too Much Good Thing

Maine Dish
An Affair to Remember
Give It to Me, Baby
Time to Draw the Line
Bushwacky
Almost There
Boss at a Loss
Flame from the Past

Sex in the City
Teen Day
Been There.
Dependent Lover

Seeing Red
Past Tense
Dazed in a Maze
Numbed by Fumes
Heartbroken
Just Do It
High & Dry
Eaten Alive
Tsunami Support
Shaking at the Knees

Southern Comfort
 
Stale Marriage
On the Brink
Same Old
Sheer Shyness
Neighborly Relations
Untrue Rumors
Florence Nightingale
Hairy Situation
Parenting the Parent
Dad's Secret Hobby
The Dude is Rude
Parents Unite!
Dad's Screams
Raised in a Barn

The World as Seen from Under His Thumb

 

Dear Claire,

 

I have been married for 20 years.  I haven't worked since my son was born 18 years ago.

 

My husband has always made decisions regarding money and expenses.  When I would say something, there was a reason my idea would not work.  He never would ask how my day went, or what I did, never.  I am not high maintenance, but I feel like someone who doesn't know who they are, someone who cannot make a decision other than dinner.

 

Finally, I said, “If you don't change, I will leave.”  He said, "I won't change, I am who I am."  I wanted counseling, but he said "no.”

 

If I leave him, nobody will be surprised.  But I need to know that I have tried everything.

 

Fed Up

 

Dear Fed Up,

 

Have you tried everything, or have you tried nothing?

 

Don’t ask your husband to change.  YOU change.

 

What this guy has done is to destroy your self-confidence little by little.  So, you’ll get it back little by little.  I do think that eventually Mr. Control Freak will lose you, but you gotta do it in the way that is best for you.

 

Instead of just packing up and leaving, here is what I would do.

 

Get a part-time job to get started.  I don’t care what.  Then go to your local junior college or any learning institution and update your job skills.  Some places also help you write a resume.  Build up a life of your own, where you do make decisions, where you are someone and where what you think matters.  Self-esteem and confidence are not gifts from Heaven.  They take building up and effort.

 

When you feel strong again, then you’ll be in a much better position to decide whether you want to stay in the marriage.

 


Web Rage

 

Dear Claire,

 

My parent's 50th wedding anniversary is coming up and I got their permission to create a website to honor them.  The problem is that four out of their six kids don't want any of their photos posted on the site (even though only their first names would be used for protection).

 

I believe they don’t want to be on the site due to "baggage" they have from all the years of my dad being an alcoholic, and the emotional and verbal abuse that comes with that.  He's no longer an alcoholic, but the relationships with the other kids have not mended.

 

Do I build the website with a place for everyone and then leave them off (which would cause my parents grief because they'll know those kids didn't want their info on the site), or do I not make any reference to them at all?  Either way, the void will look odd.

 

Dutiful Daughter

 

Dear Dutiful,

 

It’s clear that the years of abuse still pain your siblings.  It’s not a surprise that they don’t want to plaster on a smile and pretend that everything is just dandy.  If it causes your parents grief, well so be it.  There were times in your dad’s life when alcohol was more important than his children, and there is a price to pay for that even after the drinking stops.  Scars don’t disappear that easily.

 

You could build the website and mention the couple’s children (with their permission) and grandchildren.  Post pictures of those who wish it and respect the grief and anger of the others.  They are entitled to it.

02-050806-580


Send your personal letters to Ask Claire at:   

 

Would you like Ask Claire to be in your local newspaper?  Do you have comments?  If so, click here.

S
yndication information, click here.

Copyright © 2000, 2001, 2002, 2004, 2005, Claire St. John.  
Ask Claire
TM, Claire St. JohnTM,
Dear ClaireTM, Woman to Woman Straight TalkTM, www.askclaire.comTM  all rights reserved..